Cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save Items Under $2 (Perfect Filler Ideas)

If you love stretching your Amazon savings, you probably already know about the Amazon Subscribe and Save program. If you’re new, you can learn more about how Subscribe & Save works here — it’s a game‑changer for getting everyday essentials shipped straight to your door with free shipping on recurring deliveries. The kicker? You can save even more when you subscribe to 5+ items in the same month — hello, extra savings just for buying what you actually use. That’s why we keep a running list of cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items so you can quickly reach that five‑item mark without overspending.

But here’s the thing… sometimes you’re sitting at four subscriptions and just need one more cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save item to unlock that sweet discount on your entire monthly order. That’s where “filler” items come in. We rounded up over 20 cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items, all under $2, so you can hit your 5‑item goal without wasting money on things you won’t use. These tiny add‑ons can reduce the price of everything else in your shipment — win‑win!

Heads‑up for non‑Prime members: Amazon updated its policy, so you may need at least $25 (or $35 in some locations) of qualifying products in your first delivery to get free shipping. After that, recurring Subscribe & Save shipments are still free — making cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items a smart way to reach thresholds while keeping costs low.

See ALL our current Subscribe and Save deals to build your cart — then use the list below of cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items to reach your 5.

Cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save Items Under $2 (Filler List)

Here are practical, easy‑to‑use fillers to toss into your cart so you can lock in maximum savings. Most of these cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items are pantry, travel, or hygiene essentials you’ll actually use — no clutter, no regrets.

• Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening Alpine Breeze Toothpaste – Travel Size
• Advil Pain Reliever and Fever Reducer w/ Ibuprofen 200mg – 10 Coated Tablets
• Prang Board Chalk 12‑Count
• Plackers Micro Mint Dental Floss Picks w/ Travel Case 12‑Count
• Yardley Cocoa Butter Bath Soap Bar
• Luden’s Wild Cherry Throat Drops 30‑Count
• Wet n Wild Silk Finish Lipstick in Just Garnet
• Pentel R.S.V.P. Ballpoint Pen 2‑Pack
• Summer’s Eve Blissful Escape Daily Refreshing Feminine Wipes
• Happy Belly Petite Diced Tomatoes in Tomato Juice 14.5oz
• Bumble Bee Snack on the Run Chicken Salad Kit
• Q‑tips Swabs Travel Pack 30‑Count
• ChapStick Moisturizer 2‑in‑1 Lipcare SPF 15 w/ Aloe Vera and Vitamin E
• Dove Men+Care Antiperspirant Deodorant Stick 0.5oz
• Neutrogena Make‑Up Remover Cleansing Towelettes
• Bumble Bee Chunk Lite Tuna in Water 5oz
• REACH Waxed Dental Floss in Mint
• BIC Round Stic Xtra Life Black Ballpoint Pens 10‑Count
• Wet n Wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil
• L.A. Colors Craze Nail Polish
• Johnson’s Cornstarch Baby Powder with Aloe and Vitamin E 1.5oz
• The Honest Company Clean Conscious Unscented Wipes 10‑Count
• Ivory Gentle Bath Bar Soap 2‑Count

How to Maximize Savings with Cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save Items

Plan your subscriptions so they renew in the same month to unlock the higher multi‑item discount. Keep a rolling list of cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items like the ones above, and add or remove them before the cutoff date based on your household needs. If you’re close to your 5, throw in a travel‑size or pantry staple from this list to tip you over the threshold and reduce the price of everything else in your order.

Another tip: set longer delivery intervals (like every 3–6 months) for fillers you don’t go through quickly. You’ll still count them toward your 5‑item total, but you won’t get overwhelmed with extras. Watch for price changes — you can always skip, edit, or cancel before the charge date. The flexibility is a big reason we love using cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items to manage household costs without sacrificing quality.

Smart stack: combine clip‑able coupons (when available) with the 5‑item discount for the best price. It’s common to see an extra 5–20% coupon on top of Subscribe & Save — which turns these cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items into truly rock‑bottom buys. Keep your eye on our live feed of Subscribe & Save deals so you never miss an easy add that saves you more.

Click HERE to see more deals and don’t miss our Amazon Subscribe and Save Tips for advanced strategies with cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items.

Save Money on Subscribe and Save

1. Download our FREE app [CLICK HERE]
2. Tap to select the types of deals and brands you want — especially cheap Amazon Subscribe and Save items.
3. Sit back and relax… we’ll find the deals and notify you when the stuff you want costs LESS.