Frugal Cooking {How to Bake a Pumpkin}

Autumn Baking Ideas – Use Your Halloween Decorations!

How to Bake a Pumpkin Collage

{Pin This}

Chances are good, you have a few orange beauties on your front porch this month…

photo courtesy of

Did you know that even after being on display for weeks, certain pumpkins still are great for cooking? They are! As long as they don’t freeze, you can cook with pumpkins even after the Halloween and harvest festivities are over. I wanted to share with you what kinds of pumpkins are great for baking as well as give you a method of cooking pumpkins that is super easy.

I picked up the Cinderella pumpkin above at my local farmers market for $5.00. My pumpkin vendor wasn’t into making a ton of money on her punkins…she just wanted to unload them on happy customers. So I got a few. Cinderella pumpkins are short and squatty and look similar to a Cinderella carriage found in the cartoon. They have a stringy and seedy core, but a hearty meat on the inside that works great for baking. Other excellent pumpkins for baking include sugar and pie pumpkins (generally a smaller pumpkin). Your typical jack-o-lantern is NOT the best pumpkin to cook up. It’s just too stringy and watery to do you any good. Other types good for baking aren’t actually pumpkins at all…they fall in the squash category. Nice, huh? These include butternuts, hubbards, turbans, buttercup and winter squash.

So, here’s the easy peasy way to cook a pumpkin…and this way your frugal little heart will be pleased to NOT throw the pumpkins in the trash or shoot them out of a cannon at the end of the season.

How to Bake a Pumpkin

  1. Thoroughly scrub the skin of your pumpkin. Use a brush if you need to.
  2. Using a paring knife, poke a few holes into the skin. Be careful not to cut yourself!
  3. Place in a baking pan, with some of the poked holes facing up.
  4. Bake at 325 – 375 degrees until done. The amount of time depends on the size, but the pumpkin will begin to slump and be soft when it’s done. A larger cinderella pumpkin could take more than 90 minutes.
  5. Once baked, peel the pumpkin completely. Remove the seeds and strings.
  6. Mash or puree pumpkin and use in any recipe.

That’s it! A few things to note:

  • Home-baked mashed or pureed pumpkin will not be as thick as store-bought canned pumpkin. Adjust the liquid in your baking recipes to accomodate for this.
  • Regarding pureed pumpkin, in order to store it for later use, you must freeze it instead of can it. Because of its density and lack of acid, canning it is not a safe method of storing. To read more about it, check out this article.

I’ve already used my pureed pumpkin for pumpkin french toast and have plans for pumpkin waffles tomorrow.  If the recipe turns out, I will share it with you next Saturday. The rest is tucked neatly in quart-sized freezer  bags in the chest freezer. I plan on using it for pumpkin muffin Christmas gifts this year!

 {Pin This}

Cuisinart Food Processor

Cuisinart Mini-Prep Plus Food Processor – $39.95

  • FREE Shipping with Prime!
  • 250-watt food processor with 3-cup plastic work bowl
  • Chops and grinds with patented reversible stainless-steel blade
  • Simple push-button control panel; durable, yet lightweight plastic body
  • Dishwasher-safe bowl and lid for quick cleanup; spatula included

Meal Type: Halloween

Comments & Reviews

  • Now what if you want to roast the seeds, should you still cook it this method or scrape out insides and cut in pieces and put in a pan with low water and cook?

  • When I cooked the pumpkin, the seeds were still nice and wet and soft. Had I had more ambition, I would have separated the seeds from the strings and baked them with sea salt. I am sure that removing them after the initial bake and then roasting them would be just fine. Have fun!

Leave a Review/Reply

Want to see your picture by your comment? Get your custom avatar by registering for free at Gravatar.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: