Skippy Naturals Peanut Butter: Stock-up Price at Safeway!

October 26, 2011 19 Comments | Disclosure

I am working on the Safeway ad for the week and saw a deal worth highlighting especially with the upcoming price spikes on peanut butter, this deal is a definite stock up deal!

Safeway is running a promotion, Buy 4 Save $4 (mix & match).

Skippy Natural Peanut Butter, 16oz, $2.59
Buy 4 and get it for $1.59 each

Buy (2) Skippy Natural Peanut Butter until 10/29/11 and receive a $1 coupon OYNO

Deal Ideas:

Buy 4 Skippy Natural at $1.59
Pay $6.36
Get $1 catalina coupon
Final Price: $1.34 each 

Buy 2 Skippy Natural at $1.59
Buy 2 Bertolli Pasta Sauce at $1.49 (projected price)
Use $.75/2 Bertolli Coupon
Pay $5.41 and get a $1 catalina
Final Price: $1.10 each

I have confirmed this price in a Seattle store.

Thanks My Frugal Adventures!

19 Comments Filed Under: Safeway


  1. I’m headiNg to Safeway A little later…

  2. Don’t forget about the .60/2 off coupon

  3. Stephanie says:

    Would love to know if it will print 2 $1 CATS. Or if the CAT is a 2 or more?

  4. I’ve heard that it will print more than one Catalina

  5. Make sure to stock up now- I saw that peanut butter prices are going up quite a bit after october 31st!!

  6. When I bought 4, two Catalina’s for $1 printed out. That made the price $1.09 each. Has anybody else had this happen? Yeay!

  7. It printed 2 for me too!

  8. I purchased 4 lastnight and 2 $1 catalina’s printed out. Went back this morning and bought 12 and 6 $1 catalina’s printed out. HOWEVER, today the price for the peanutbutter was $1 more each. I was confused after checking out (have a little one that distracts me) and recomputed the total and was correct, that after the $4 off per 4 the “sale” price was $2.59 each. Talked with manager and he saw they printed up new tags overnight and adjusted price because of the peanut shortage. He was very nice and honored the previous night’s price, but I’m sure he won’t be doing that any more. I’m not sure if it was just our safeway, or if it’s an every store thing. Be sure to check the prices before grabbing and running to the checkout.

    • Misty Wiser says:

      This happened in my stores as well….. I am so glad I purchased some last night, but a little upset that I only got 8….. I also think since the tag said valid until nov 1, they should have left it until nov 1st.

  9. I have noticed some peelies for $1/2

  10. I bought 4 Skippy Naturals tonight, 10/28. This is how it worked out on my tag:

    $4.99 x 4 = $19.96 (yes, $4.99 regular price!)
    Club save = – 5.60
    B4save$4 = – 4.00
    2 .60/2 q’s = – 1.20
    Total $ 9.16

    Plus 2 $1 catalinas = $7.16 divided by 4 = $1.79 each

Leave a Comment
Want to see your picture by your comment? Get your custom avatar by registering for free at Gravatar.